91原创

Skip to content

Painful Truth: Is it a bubble if it never bursts?

Housing markets do not make sense, and maybe they never will
24674885_web1_Housing-RealEstate1280

Housing in Canada, and especially in B.C., is again going bonkers. Prices are up by ludicrous amounts. People are flinging cash, sight unseen, bidding wars are breaking out 鈥 it all feels pretty familiar, doesn鈥檛 it?

Since the early 2000s, in the years leading up to the Great Recession, we鈥檝e had multiple sharp increases in property values. Each one has prompted flurries of doomsaying 鈥 including some from me 鈥 about how it would all end in tears, surely there鈥檇 be a crash, speculators would go broke, homeowners would find themselves underwater and struggling to make payments, finally we would have sensible real estate prices.

Well, that hasn鈥檛 happened yet.

We鈥檝e had a couple of extremely brief corrections, neither of which did more than partially deflate the bubble, and after each of them, it seemed to inflate faster than before!

So now I don鈥檛 know. Maybe it鈥檚 a forever bubble. Maybe prices really won鈥檛 come down. Maybe, as everyone is so fond of saying, it is about 鈥渟trong economic fundamentals.鈥 Fundamental what, I don鈥檛 know.

I鈥檝e entirely lost the ability to be shocked by the local property market. I just shrug every time some deranged new stat is announced.

In the last few months, the average price of detached residential property in the Fraser Valley has graphed as a near-vertical line; in February it approached $1.4 million.

Sure, why not?

A house in Walnut Grove sells for $500,000 over its asking price?

Fine, totally normal.

It will take 11 years for an average couple to save up enough for a down payment for a house at current prices? Well, that鈥檚 cheap. It鈥檚 26 years in Greater Vancouver!

I guess those youngsters will just have to give up their avocado toast and fancy lattes, and save like their parents did when houses cost $50,000!

I honestly don鈥檛 know what to say about the current real estate market.

It鈥檚 obviously a bad thing. It鈥檚 sucking up so much money that it鈥檚 deforming the rest of the Canadian economy. For people buying into the market now, almost no money will go towards retirement savings or investing, because everything is going to the house. The house is the retirement plan; for many folks, there is no Plan B.

And it shouldn鈥檛 work. It鈥檚 like a Jenga tower, held up by the extremely shaky supports of low interest rates, FOMO, and moral hazard.

There鈥檚 basically no good options. Four or five years ago, I was rooting for a major correction in the housing market, but now I can鈥檛 do that.

All the options are bad.

A major correction wipes out vast amounts of 鈥渨ealth鈥 held by ordinary people. It will put thousands out of work. It could damage the entire national economy.

On the other hand, no correction, full steam ahead, just enriches flippers and the already-wealthy, and turns Canadian cities into hollowed-out playgrounds for property speculators. It鈥檒l kill our communities and disinherit the next several generations.

But hey. Maybe I鈥檓 wrong.

Maybe it鈥檚 not a bubble. Maybe it鈥檚 just strong economic fundamentals.



Matthew Claxton

About the Author: Matthew Claxton

Raised in 91原创, as a journalist today I focus on local politics, crime and homelessness.
Read more



(or

91原创

) document.head.appendChild(flippScript); window.flippxp = window.flippxp || {run: []}; window.flippxp.run.push(function() { window.flippxp.registerSlot("#flipp-ux-slot-ssdaw212", "Black Press Media Standard", 1281409, [312035]); }); }