91原创

Skip to content

THE MOJ: Ovechkin versus Gretzky sparks many a spirited debate

Best way to compare elite athletes is their dominance against their peers
31424462_web1_221227-BPD-Moj-column-ovie_1
Washington Capitals left wing Alex Ovechkin (8) skates with the puck during the first period of an NHL hockey game against the Winnipeg Jets, Friday, Dec. 23, 2022, in Washington. (AP Photo/Nick Wass)

With Alexander Ovechkin scoring his 802nd NHL goal and passing Gordie Howe as the league鈥檚 second all-time leading goal scorer, the debate continues as to whether or not he can catch Wayne Gretzky, who finished his illustrious career with 894.

Ovechkin鈥檚 two goals in Friday night鈥檚 4-1 win over the Winnipeg Jets moved him to within 92 goals of The Great One.

The debate on whether or not Ovechkin can overtake Gretzky isn鈥檛 the only one that is taking place 鈥 I鈥檝e actually even heard discussions on who is the better goal scorer and the better player.

The argument that you hear from those who favour Ovechkin is that he is a far superior athlete when it comes to a physical skill set than Gretzky 鈥 and I鈥檇 agree.

If you were to put Ovechkin in the DeLorean with Marty McFly and drop him off in 1982, he would be Biff Tannen on skates. At the same time, if you picked up Gretzky and time travelled to 2022, he wouldn鈥檛 be as great.

But it鈥檚 almost impossible to compare the two because there are so many different 鈥 and fluid - factors that weigh into the debate.

Ovechkin is the beneficiary of advancements in physical conditioning, equipment, skill development, scouting, nutrition, etc., that Gretzky could never access.

Physically comparing the two athletes is absurd. The same goes with comparing Connor McDavid, Nathan MacKinnon or any other superstar from today鈥檚 era to the likes of Howe, Phil Esposito and Guy Lafleur.

Yet Gretzky and his contemporaries had their advantages, too.

Former NHLer and current ESPN analyst Ray Ferraro always liked to point out that the gap between the top six and the bottom six of team鈥檚 forward group has narrowed considerably over the years because of the aforementioned advancements.

Gretzky could feast on mismatches because the floor of the talent level was so much lower in his era. Ovechkin doesn鈥檛 have the same luxury.

And as far as goaltending is concerned, watching the position being played in the 1980s is almost comical. I鈥檝e always argued that no other position in sport has transformed itself more than goaltending in the last half-century.

READ MORE:

Then again, I鈥檝e never been a fan of comparing athletes from different eras.

What I am a fan of is comparing the level of domination of athletes from different eras.

Ovechkin has led the league in scoring on nine different occasions, Gretzky managed the same feat five times.

Gretzky鈥檚 career-high was 92 goals in 1981-82 鈥 which was 28 more than the next closest player in Mike Bossy.

Ovechkin鈥檚 best tally was the 65 goals he scored in 2007-08 鈥 which was 13 goals better than Atlanta鈥檚 Ilya Kovalchuk鈥檚 52.

Those are the types of numbers that should be used to determine who was the more 鈥榙ominant鈥 player.

And if you want to talk about how dominant Gretzky was versus his peers, look no further than the 1985-86 season in which he scored 52 goals and added 163 assists to finish with 215 points. Some guy named Mario Lemieux finished second in scoring that season with 141 points. In other words, Gretzky had more assists than Lemieux had points.

Gretzky鈥檚 dominance was such that some hockey pools would either make him ineligible or split his goals and assist totals into separate two categories.

When Barry Bonds finished his career with 762 home runs and was drawing comparisons to Hank Aaron and Babe Ruth, I shook my head again for the same reasons that I mentioned earlier when talking about Gretzky and Ovechkin.

When it came to who was the more dominant player in his generation, it was easily Ruth and it wasn鈥檛 even close.

In 1920, Ruth hit 54 home runs for the New York Yankees. The next closest player was George Sisler from St. Louis 鈥 who hit 19. In 1921, Ruth hit 59 homers with the next closest being his teammate Bob Meusel who hit 24.

I could go on but you get the idea.

If you want to debate about who is the better or more dominant player, comparing players from different generations is a flawed argument.

Compare them against their peers and you鈥檒l find out who truly was great and or dominant.

Veteran B.C. sports personality Bob 鈥渢he Moj鈥 Marjanovich writes twice weekly for Black Press Media. And check out his weekly podcast every Monday at or your local Black Press Media website.

THE MOJ:



Black Press Media Staff

About the Author: Black Press Media Staff

Read more



(or

91原创

) document.head.appendChild(flippScript); window.flippxp = window.flippxp || {run: []}; window.flippxp.run.push(function() { window.flippxp.registerSlot("#flipp-ux-slot-ssdaw212", "Black Press Media Standard", 1281409, [312035]); }); }